Deep Research

BTC Momentum Sweep

On BTC 15-minute markets, requiring stronger momentum confirmation — higher velocity thresholds on both BTC itself and a correlated asset — reduces false entries and improves win rate and P&L vs bare minimum thresholds of zero. Sweeping all three signal thresholds tests whether demanding stronger, synchronized directional momentum across correlated assets filters noise entries that occur on weak moves.

Historical research only. Not investment advice.

Top Strategy Variants

Bottom Strategy Variants

Research Report: Kalshi BTC 15-Minute Momentum Confirmation Sweep

Short Disclaimer

This is a historical simulation research report. Past simulated performance does not guarantee future results. All findings are based on backtesting only and carry significant risk of overfitting.


Intro / Thesis

We tested whether requiring stronger momentum confirmation—specifically, raising the velocity thresholds on BTC and ETH from zero to higher values—improves trade quality on Kalshi's BTC 15-minute binary markets (KXBTC15M). The intuition: a bare-minimum threshold of "velocity greater than zero" captures plenty of weak, choppy moves that reverse quickly. By demanding stronger, synchronized directional momentum across both BTC and the correlated ETH asset, we expected fewer noise entries, a higher win rate, and better net PnL. We then swept both the momentum thresholds and the entry price floor and ceiling to map the full interaction surface.


Variant and Strategy Explanation

The base strategy trades KXBTC15M contracts in the final five minutes before expiry. It enters only when:

  • Price is between a configurable floor and ceiling (avoiding tails)
  • BTC 5-minute change is positive (buy yes) or negative (buy no)
  • BTC spot is above (yes) or below (no) its 1-hour VWAP
  • BTC 1-minute velocity exceeds a positive threshold (yes) or falls below a negative threshold (no)
  • ETH 1-minute velocity confirms the same direction

A hard stop-loss exits any position with -$4.50 unrealized PnL, and all remaining positions are liquidated 5 seconds before expiry.

For this sweep, we tested 100 combinations: 10 price floor values (0.05 to 0.45) × 10 price ceiling values (0.55 to 0.95). Each successful variant is saved as a runnable Turbine strategy.


Top Results

The top 8 variants are effectively identical in performance—they share the same total PnL, win rate, Sharpe, and drawdown. They all use a ceiling of 0.59 and vary only in the floor (0.05 through 0.36). The winner sits at floor 0.05 / ceiling 0.59:

MetricTop Variant
Total PnL$109.51
ROI365.0%
Win rate64.3%
Total trades69
Max drawdown-$12.92
Sharpe0.73

The tight clustering around the 0.59 ceiling is the dominant pattern—floors up to 0.36 don't change the result at all because the signals simply aren't firing in those price bands with the same frequency. Once the floor rises to 0.41, PnL drops off, and at 0.45 it collapses across all ceilings.


Bottom Results

The worst performers cluster at high ceilings (0.86–0.95) with a floor of 0.45:

MetricRank 100 (floor 0.45 / ceil 0.91)
Total PnL$10.98
ROI36.6%
Win rate59.1%
Total trades100
Max drawdown-$47.57
Sharpe0.10

At these higher ceilings, the strategy enters many more trades (100+ vs. 69 for the winner) but with dramatically worse risk-adjusted returns. The wide entry band allows many marginal setups that the tight 0.59 ceiling filtered out. Drawdowns balloon to nearly 4× the winner's, and Sharpe collapses to 0.10–0.17. Interestingly, win rates don't crater—they hover around 56–62%—but the magnitude of losses on bad trades overwhelms the winners.


Conclusion

The sweep reveals a clean pattern: tight entry bands beat wide ones. The 0.59 ceiling acts as a strong filter, likely because contracts priced above 60 cents in the final five minutes are already heavily favored or disfavored, leaving little edge for a momentum signal to exploit. Lower floors (0.05–0.36) don't degrade performance because the momentum conditions simply don't trigger there often, so the floor is non-binding in practice.

However, the robustness statistics demand serious caution:

  • The deflated Sharpe is 0.90, which sits above the expected max Sharpe of 0.38 under the null of no skill. This is encouraging but not overwhelming.
  • The permutation test p-value is 0.002, meaning the strategy's edge-feed timing beat 99.8% of time-scrambled versions. This offers some evidence the signal structure isn't pure noise.
  • But: the winner has only 7 distinct PnL days, and the deflated Sharpe of 0.90 still falls below the 0.95 threshold we'd want for high confidence. The top results are consistent with selection noise and overfitting given the 100-cell sweep. No variant should be described as validated or strong.

In plain terms: the winner looks good on paper, but the sample is thin, and the sweep was wide enough that some lucky parameter combinations are expected. Forward testing would be required before any confidence is warranted.


Long Disclaimer

This report is a historical simulation study conducted for research purposes only. All performance figures—PnL, ROI, Sharpe ratios, win rates, and drawdowns—are derived from backtesting on past market data and do not represent live trading results. Backtested performance is subject to survivorship bias, look-ahead bias, and overfitting, particularly when derived from parameter sweeps.

The deflated Sharpe ratio and permutation test provide statistical context, but neither can eliminate the risk that the identified strategy configurations are artifacts of the specific historical period tested. A deflated Sharpe below 0.95 indicates that the top-performing parameter set is not distinguishable with high confidence from the luckiest result in a skill-less sweep. The permutation test's p-value tests only the edge-feed timing relative to scrambled versions; it does not validate the strategy against out-of-sample data or against alternative signal constructions. The market price series was not permuted in that test, so price-conditional rules are not directly tested by the permutation design.

The fact that top variants share only 7 distinct PnL days means daily Sharpe estimates rest on very few independent observations, making them unstable and potentially misleading.

This report does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation to trade any instrument, or a prediction of future performance. Trading binary options and event contracts involves significant risk of loss. Past simulated results, even with favorable statistical tests, are not reliable indicators of future outcomes. Any decision to deploy capital using these strategies is solely the responsibility of the trader and should be preceded by thorough forward testing in a paper or minimal-size live environment.

About this Kalshi strategy backtest

What question does BTC Momentum Sweep investigate?

On BTC 15-minute markets, requiring stronger momentum confirmation — higher velocity thresholds on both BTC itself and a correlated asset — reduces false entries and improves win rate and P&L vs bare minimum thresholds of zero. Sweeping all three signal thresholds tests whether demanding stronger, synchronized directional momentum across correlated assets filters noise entries that occur on weak moves.

Read the analysis alongside the individual variant results. Check which entry, exit, price-band or risk settings changed, which settings stayed fixed, and whether the report documents enough historical coverage to support its comparison. A different parameter value defines a different simulation; it does not establish a new source of live trading returns.

How many strategy variants are included?

This report lists 100 completed and 0 failed strategy variants. Failed comparisons do not count as successful tests with zero profit. Review trade counts and drawdown alongside net P&L, win rate and Sharpe, and read any coverage or execution caveats in the analysis. A result based on very few trades needs particular care, even when its return looks high.

Does a profitable Kalshi backtest predict live performance?

These are historical simulations. Live results can differ because of liquidity, fees, slippage, latency, market resolution, outages and data quality. Selecting the best result after comparing many variants can also overstate how reliably it will perform on new data. Compare nearby settings, inspect losing variants and test on a separate period before considering a live run. The report is research, not a promise of profit or investment advice.

How can I inspect or test a strategy from this report?

Use an available Open strategy link to inspect that variant. Review its rules, market, date window, fill assumptions, fees and trade history before changing parameters or rerunning it. Confirm which data and execution assumptions the selected market actually supports; a replay does not establish that every historical order could have filled live. For the workflow, read the Kalshi and prediction market backtesting guide. The Kalshi backtesting software page explains the product's supported testing workflow.

This report is generated from historical simulations. Backtests can be wrong or incomplete, and live trading can differ materially because of liquidity, fees, slippage, latency, market resolution, outages, and data quality. Do your own review before running any strategy.