Deep Research

VWAP Momentum Wide

When BTC spot price is above 1h VWAP with positive 5-minute momentum, KXBTC15M YES contracts tend to be undervalued; when below with negative momentum, NO contracts tend to be undervalued. The wider 0.10-0.90 price band captures more entry opportunities compared to tighter bands.

Historical research only. Not investment advice.

Top Strategy Variants

Bottom Strategy Variants

Research Report: Kalshi KXBTC15M — VWAP & Momentum Strategy Simulation

Short Disclaimer This is a historical simulation study. Past performance does not guarantee future results. All figures are hypothetical and net of friction assumptions.


Intro / Thesis

We tested whether combining BTC spot price relative to its one-hour volume-weighted average price (1h VWAP) with short-term 5-minute momentum creates a systematic edge in Kalshi’s 15-minute BTC binary options (KXBTC15M). The core idea: when BTC trades above 1h VWAP and has positive 5m momentum, YES contracts are perceived to be undervalued; below VWAP with negative momentum, NO contracts appear undervalued. We also wanted to see if a wide entry price band (0.10–0.90) captures more opportunities than narrower bands without degrading trade quality.

Variant and Strategy Explanation

The base strategy uses live Coinbase data (spot price, 1h VWAP, and 5-minute percent change) refreshed every 10 seconds. It runs a 30-second decision loop on KXBTC15M contracts.

Rules are simple:

  • Buy YES when BTC > 1h VWAP, 5m change > +0.05%, contract price within 0.10–0.90, spread ≤ 0.03, and more than 2 minutes until expiry.
  • Buy NO when BTC < 1h VWAP, 5m change < –0.05%, same price/spread/time constraints.
  • Stop loss at –$25 unrealized PnL on any open position.
  • Forced exit when ≤2 minutes to expiry.

100 variants were generated from this base. Each variant modifies parameters like entry thresholds, spread tolerance, price band edges, stop-loss levels, or momentum values. All runs are complete; 100 strategies were simulated, producing top and bottom cohorts measured by ROI, Sharpe, drawdown, total PnL, win rate, and trade count.

Top Results

The top-performing variants are disappointing by any conventional measure. Every single top-ranked strategy lost money — heavily.

RankVariantROI %SharpeMax DD %Win RateTotal PnLTrades
1v017–304.2–1.58–93.32%10.37%–$76.053,787
2v018–304.2–1.58–93.32%10.37%–$76.053,787
3v019–304.2–1.58–93.32%10.37%–$76.053,787
4v020–304.2–1.58–93.32%10.37%–$76.053,787
5v037–306.4–1.68–94.07%10.55%–$76.603,849
6v038–306.4–1.68–94.07%10.55%–$76.603,849
7v039–306.4–1.68–94.07%10.55%–$76.603,849
8v040–306.4–1.68–94.07%10.55%–$76.603,849

These strategies all share similar characteristics: win rates around 10–11%, massive drawdowns exceeding 90%, and deeply negative Sharpe ratios. The wide 0.10–0.90 price band did generate high trade volumes (3,700–3,800+) but each additional trade appeared to pile on losses. Despite capturing many entry opportunities, the edge was negative — the market consistently priced these contracts correctly or against our signals. The stop loss at –$25 was triggered frequently, locking in small losses that compounded into large drawdowns across thousands of trades.

None of these top variants represent a viable trading approach. They are labeled “top” only by relative rank within a uniformly loss-making population.

Bottom Results

The worst performers are even more destructive, though the gap between “top” and “bottom” is narrow.

RankVariantROI %SharpeMax DD %Win RateTotal PnLTrades
93v061–1248.80.0–76.13%10.96%–$62.443,348
94v062–1248.80.0–76.13%10.96%–$62.443,348
95v063–1248.80.0–76.13%10.96%–$62.443,348
96v064–1248.80.0–76.13%10.96%–$62.443,348
97v081–1250.20.0–76.27%10.89%–$62.513,374
98v082–1250.20.0–76.27%10.89%–$62.513,374
99v083–1250.20.0–76.27%10.89%–$62.513,374
100v084–1250.20.0–76.27%10.89%–$62.513,374

Win rates here are marginally higher (around 10.9%) than the top group, and total dollar losses are slightly lower ($62 vs $76), but ROI percentages are catastrophic — the denominator effect of smaller average position sizing or account equity makes the percentage loss look worse. Sharpe ratios register as zero due to consistently negative returns with near-zero volatility of that negative drift. These bottom variants likely used slightly different stop-loss or size parameters that reduced absolute dollar loss but still produced uniformly negative results.

Conclusion

The VWAP-plus-momentum thesis on KXBTC15M contracts fails dramatically in historical simulation. None of the 100 variants produced a profit. Win rates hover stubbornly around 10–11%, suggesting the binary outcomes move against our signals roughly 90% of the time. The wide 0.10–0.90 price band succeeded in increasing trade frequency but merely amplified losses — more entries meant more losing trades, not more winners. Stop losses at –$25 acted as a death by a thousand cuts. Tight spreads and proximity to expiry offered no shelter.

This concept, at least in this exact formulation on Kalshi’s 15-minute BTC binaries, does not demonstrate an exploitable edge. The market appears efficient relative to this signal set. Each successful variant from the simulation is saved as a runnable Turbine strategy for audit and further study, but we do not recommend live deployment of any variant in this cohort.


Long Disclaimer This document is produced for research and informational purposes only. All results are derived from historical simulations conducted in a controlled backtesting environment. They do not represent actual trading, live account performance, or future outcomes. Simulated results are subject to limitations including, but not limited to, imperfect modeling of liquidity, execution latency, exchange fees, and market impact. Any strategy discussed here — including saved runnable variants — carries significant risk of loss. Past simulated performance is not indicative of future results. This is not financial advice, a solicitation, or a recommendation to trade any instrument on any venue. Consult a qualified professional before engaging in speculative trading.

About this Kalshi strategy backtest

What question does VWAP Momentum Wide investigate?

When BTC spot price is above 1h VWAP with positive 5-minute momentum, KXBTC15M YES contracts tend to be undervalued; when below with negative momentum, NO contracts tend to be undervalued. The wider 0.10-0.90 price band captures more entry opportunities compared to tighter bands.

Read the analysis alongside the individual variant results. Check which entry, exit, price-band or risk settings changed, which settings stayed fixed, and whether the report documents enough historical coverage to support its comparison. A different parameter value defines a different simulation; it does not establish a new source of live trading returns.

How many strategy variants are included?

This report lists 100 completed and 0 failed strategy variants. Failed comparisons do not count as successful tests with zero profit. Review trade counts and drawdown alongside net P&L, win rate and Sharpe, and read any coverage or execution caveats in the analysis. A result based on very few trades needs particular care, even when its return looks high.

Does a profitable Kalshi backtest predict live performance?

These are historical simulations. Live results can differ because of liquidity, fees, slippage, latency, market resolution, outages and data quality. Selecting the best result after comparing many variants can also overstate how reliably it will perform on new data. Compare nearby settings, inspect losing variants and test on a separate period before considering a live run. The report is research, not a promise of profit or investment advice.

How can I inspect or test a strategy from this report?

Use an available Open strategy link to inspect that variant. Review its rules, market, date window, fill assumptions, fees and trade history before changing parameters or rerunning it. Confirm which data and execution assumptions the selected market actually supports; a replay does not establish that every historical order could have filled live. For the workflow, read the Kalshi and prediction market backtesting guide. The Kalshi backtesting software page explains the product's supported testing workflow.

This report is generated from historical simulations. Backtests can be wrong or incomplete, and live trading can differ materially because of liquidity, fees, slippage, latency, market resolution, outages, and data quality. Do your own review before running any strategy.